The implementation of smart cities process in Morocco, the challenges, issues and opportunities

Introduction

Smart cities rely on the adoption and integration of advanced technologies to achieve urban and local development goals. These projects aim to improve the quality of life for citizens and the sustainability of their environments, making urban societies stable, sustainable, and viable (UNDP, 2014). The adoption of Internet of Things (IoT) devices and direct, permanent surveillance camera systems are the cornerstone of these computerization and urban planning projects. Morocco has integrated into similar processes, such as the adoption of IoT-based surveillance systems, biometric access control, and data collection and analysis (Khalifi et al. 2024). These processes have revolutionized real-time surveillance, improved spatial awareness and decision-making processes, and provided crucial information on traffic, environmental conditions, and security incidents in an interoperable manner (Townsend, 2013).

These devices have optimized resources and strengthened proactive measures in urban management, with IoT-connected sensors capable of remotely detecting anomalies in infrastructure, thereby reducing intervention costs and improving safety (Zanell et al. 2014). Direct surveillance through connected cameras enjoys an excellent reputation in crime prevention, traffic management, and the improvement of public safety (Gill et al. 2005). However, the drawbacks related to data and transaction privacy, ethical implications, and transparency issues prompt a reconsideration of this situation from a specific and original perspective.

Morocco offers a specific context with exceptional advantages to test the integration of these processes within a society that has historically been conservative but harbors significant ambitions for modernization. For the past ten years, Morocco has demonstrated its interest in modernizing infrastructure and improving governance. The integration of smart city projects, particularly in Casablanca and Rabat, confirms this commitment to benefiting from IoT devices, similar to those that have previously undergone urban digitization processes and maintained urban security technologies to consolidate urban security and promote economic growth and environmental sustainability (Bouazzaoui et al. 2020).

Our intervention aims to clarify the path and strategy to harmonize the use of IoT devices and direct surveillance camera systems with Moroccan specificities without compromising the effectiveness of these systems or threatening the societal context. This will only be achievable with the proposal of a roadmap that takes into account Morocco’s requirements on an equal footing with calls for the accelerated integration of technologies into urban processes. The conclusions of this work will help municipal decision-makers, local urban planning strategists, and urban policy implementation officials to effectively avoid undesirable scenarios and transition the use of urban security technologies towards a phase of security, stability, and prosperity.

The Basic Technologies for the Implementation of Smart Cities

The adoption of IoT devices for real-time monitoring, data collection, and direct permanent surveillance cameras is becoming a common procedure in urban strategies to ensure urban security. Moroccan cities are increasingly adopting these technologies to improve public urban safety, service enhancement and management, resource optimization, and other urban activities. These technologies improve urban safety by increasing situational awareness, the efficiency of real-time data processing, and a more effective response to incidents. They also enable municipal authorities to shape traffic management, handle environmental risks more sustainably, and consolidate public safety (Costa et al. 2024).

Moroccan cities, such as Casablanca, Rabat, and Tangier, are striving to join the international club of smart cities by adopting and integrating IoT systems to address traffic issues, surveillance, crime prevention, and biometric access control within their territory (Khalifi et al., 2024). By leveraging the capabilities of IoT devices and systems in terms of surveillance, automated decision-making, and proactive security, Moroccan cities aim to achieve profiles similar to those of international cities like Barcelona and Singapore, which have succeeded in optimizing traffic flow, energy consumption, and urban security through the use of these devices.

However, the implementation of these technologies raises several technical, ethical, or financial aspects. The introduction of these devices must take into account the weaknesses of cybersecurity protocols, the potential dangers related to data privacy and storage, as well as the level of digital literacy, all of which risk overturning the advantages of IoT devices (Ferrer 2017). The example of cyberattacks targeting the vital infrastructures of smart cities internationally serves as evidence of the weaknesses of these devices and systems in the face of challenges and threats.

The adoption of IoT devices in Morocco represents significant advancements for the improvement of urban management and planning tasks. Direct surveillance camera devices represent a step forward in the fight against urban crime and the deterrence of malicious individuals seeking to exploit the vulnerabilities of these devices to achieve criminal objectives (Fontes et al. 2022). However, these cameras raise ethical concerns, questions related to the respect of citizens’ privacy, inquiries attached to governance models and modalities, as well as potential abuses of personal data.

The existing legal frameworks in Morocco, particularly those related to the processing and protection of personal data, are still vulnerable to the evolving issues and challenges related to data management and organization. The presence of a specific legal and legislative framework is essential to prevent impacts and balance security needs with the requirements of law and privacy, thus giving Morocco an advantage in its process of adopting IoT devices for urban planning and security reasons (Elmaghraby and Losavio 2014).

Moroccan decision-makers will need to prioritize regulatory alignment and legal complementarity to ensure compatibility between the objectives set by municipal authorities and the operational requirements for the adoption of IoT in Moroccan cities. By developing similar frameworks based on this experience and prioritizing the implementation of a specific national policy, Morocco can maximize the benefits of its smart city projects and succeed where previous experiences have failed.

Exploring Opportunities for Moroccan Cities by Adopting Urban Technologies

Morocco is experiencing rapid urbanization, posing multiple challenges to the state and municipal organizations. To address these issues, Morocco is engaging in specific processes, such as urban digitization, which has proven to be effective and operational. Urban security technologies offer solutions to public safety and community stability issues, providing societies with great potential to improve their lives (Belguidoum, Cattedra and Iraki 2015).

Moroccan cities suffer from overpopulation due to development disparities, rural depopulation, and industrialization processes. More than 60% of the population lives in urban areas, and the major cities of Morocco are affected by this overpopulation, which puts pressure on public services, increases crime rates, and jeopardizes transportation. This has led to the isolation of the majority of Moroccan cities, which are vulnerable to social destabilization, cyberattacks, and the mismanagement of already depleted resources (Саpցеmіոі Rеsеаrсh Iոstіtսtе 2020).

Technologies as a solution for smart cities can overcome overpopulation issues and enable human gatherings to function efficiently through data analysis and processing. For example, the introduction of technologies in the urban field has helped improve traffic flow and management, energy consumption, as well as crisis and emergency management systems. This is particularly relevant for Moroccan cities, especially in case of emergencies due to overloaded services and organizational challenges (Woetzel et al. 2018). More specifically, the security technologies on which this work focuses can make a difference and transform these discussion spaces into sustainable and safer environments. 7

The introduction of IoT devices in the process of real-time monitoring and data collection allows local authorities to analyze information and make on-the-ground decisions based on technological potential for real-time data analysis (Costa et al. 2024b). These analyzed statistics can vary depending on the areas of the city’s composition, such as public safety, environmental data, air quality, traffic estimation, and incidents of safety and crime in the urban environment.

A study by the World Economic Forum (2016) confirmed that the adoption of interconnected security systems in smart cities could improve public safety by 20%. This means that these processes of digitization and connectivity in urbanization will lead to an improvement as the hypotheses require, and will reduce crime rates as well as response times to harmful practices. IoT applications in the field of public safety, particularly public surveillance camera systems, can provide direct and continuous monitoring of common goods and infrastructures to prevent practices that could harm these common goods (Thakuriah, Tilahun and Moira 2015).

However, the introduction of IoT technologies must be done with caution, taking into account the legal and security impacts of data integrity breaches and avoiding violations of privacy laws. Morocco should strengthen the framework for using these technologies based on the specific objectives of urban planning and improve the legislation, institutions, and agencies that integrate modern urbanization plans and strategies.

The implementation of direct and permanent surveillance camera systems is crucial for preventing crimes and monitoring areas of criminal proliferation and hotspots in cities. In smart cities, traditional video surveillance systems are currently supported by AI applications that enable automated monitoring, aiming to enhance their real-time activities such as tracking individuals, providing valuable information, detecting suspects, or predicting criminal behaviors (Brittjons 2024).

In Morocco, the implementation of AI-assisted surveillance systems can enhance the capabilities of local authorities to make their interventions in sensitive areas more effective. This process can also lead to crime prevention through the development of special programs aimed at addressing the social environment that attracts people to these criminal areas. However, the use of AI in video surveillance without any consideration can lead to undesirable and unforeseen circumstances. Ethical considerations must be taken into account when integrating AI capabilities into surveillance processes and camera surveillance of urban areas, as the data and information collected for facial recognition can be used to infringe on individuals’ rights.

Biometric identification systems, such as fingerprint identification, facial recognition, and iris scans, are increasingly being used in smart cities around the world due to their unprecedented potential to secure public property, vital infrastructure, and essential services for the survival of the city and its citizens. The adoption of these systems and their integration into current urbanization activities can significantly improve urban security rates (Nakar et al. 2017). For example, biometric identity systems could be installed at key points in Moroccan cities, such as airports, government establishments, secure zones, and important high-security locations, to prevent unauthorized access (Khan et al. 2021).

However, the limitations of this technology must be acknowledged. Although these technologies offer great potential to facilitate the work of local authorities, any malfunction of their fingerprint or facial recognition systems, or in the event of a cyberattack or cybersecurity breach in these systems, will result in serious errors in intervention and deterrence protocols and procedures. To avoid these situations, Morocco is supposed to ensure that biometric identification systems comply with international standards, such as ISO/IEC 29115, which provides the necessary guidelines for the development and implementation of biometric systems (Liu and Guo 2019).

The opportunities for smart cities in Morocco include the growth of sustainable development across all communities, job creation, improvement of public safety, and enhancement of the quality of life for citizens in sensitive areas (Вοѕоοѕа et al. 2024). Mixed partnership processes between the public sector, the private sector, and academic institutions play an essential role in improving the adoption rate of smart city technologies according to this paradigm.

The smart city as a development sector can stimulate the creation of local opportunities, particularly in the fields of technology, engineering, data analysis, and cybersecurity. For this approach, the demand for qualified professionals capable of managing, maintaining, and developing these systems will only grow, thus offering hope for economic growth in the regions and for the country as a whole (МсKіnѕеу Ꮐlоbаl Iոѕtitսtе 2018). Taking into account the well-known experiences of smart cities in the Arab world, such as Dubai and Abu Dhabi, Morocco can build a unique and efficient smart city system that can be implemented in various sectors, including public safety, security, and economic growth.

Problems that Can Arise During the Implementation of Smart City Projects

Urban security technologies are becoming increasingly important in smart city projects and the strategic planning of urbanization, but Moroccan cities must pay attention to significant challenges and not base their objectives solely on these projects (Abdelkhalk et al. 2021). The privacy associated with data collection and surveillance, the risks and challenges of cybersecurity related to IoT devices, as well as the challenges of integrating new technologies with national infrastructures still under development, all support the critical perspective we have towards these technologies (Chουrаіkеt et al. 2024).

Privacy issues related to data collection, surveillance, and cybersecurity risks are significant (Kolotouchkina et al. 2014). In the transformed smart cities of Morocco, the massive collection of private data can raise concerns about violations of citizens’ rights on different scales and pose undesirable questions about rights and freedoms. The permanent use of surveillance cameras in public spaces, equipped with facial recognition and AI technologies, can raise doubts among citizens when they feel constantly monitored and controlled every second of their lives and in every activity. This feeling of invasion of privacy among citizens is likely to grow and increase due to the massive implementation of these technologies without awareness of the related issues, which could potentially lead in some cases and situations to violent reactions or resistance against the implementation of these urban security technologies.

In Rabat, one of Morocco’s smart cities, many municipalities are equipped with surveillance cameras to monitor traffic and improve public safety. These measures, although they have positively improved the situation, have also achieved their objectives. They pose privacy risks, and reports indicate that some residents have expressed concerns about being monitored without their consent, highlighting the importance of having community planning and management agreements in place before the implementation of these technologies (Elhamdouni et al. 2023).

The proliferation of IoT in urban spaces makes these processes vulnerable to cyberattacks and other forms of electronic interference, infiltrations, and other cyber threats. In Morocco, smart cities must address these risks by engaging in comprehensive negotiation and consultation processes with various stakeholders to find solutions to the risks and challenges posed by the implementation of these technologies. The integration of urban security technologies with existing infrastructures is a major challenge for Moroccan cities aspiring to become smart cities.

These cities currently rely on outdated systems that may not be compatible with advanced systems like biometric systems, which can lead to technical and financial obstacles. For example, Rabat faces challenges related to the vulnerability of aging infrastructure networks and risks being incompatible with the new software requirements for buses and trams. Upgrading these networks and infrastructures requires considerable efforts, financial resources, and organizational arrangements, although these cities still do not have the necessary budgets to fully achieve their objectives.

In such situations, hybrid partnerships can provide a solution, allowing Moroccan cities to overcome financial barriers and benefit from private sector expertise in this field. The implementation of smart technologies in other Moroccan cities can help mitigate the challenges and issues related to traffic and surveillance services in specific areas of the city. Collaboration with internationally renowned technology companies in the field of smart cities can facilitate Morocco’s integration into the global wave of digitization and avoid undesirable impacts.

Despite the numerous challenges, it is crucial to take the necessary measures and responses to avoid long-term impacts on the stability of economic development and social equity. The processes of urban digitization and the integration of smart cities could lead to an unprecedented increase in investments and economic growth. As cities become more stable, secure, and with lower crime rates, they will attract more businesses and investments, contribute to job creation, and generate local wealth.

To ensure equality and equity in smart cities, Moroccan cities should engage in serious inclusion processes involving community stakeholders in planning and integration processes. Municipal councils and community forums can invite citizens to express their opinions on proposed smart city projects, thereby fostering a sense of belonging, engagement, and responsibility.

Investing in special programs such as education and training for citizens, particularly in disadvantaged areas through targeted prevention, can help reduce inequalities, promote social equity, and increase citizen inclusion in smart urbanization plans. Regular evaluations of initiatives and planning efforts are also essential to ensure the effectiveness of these efforts and to strengthen societal trust in the future if Morocco chooses to generate this experience.

Successful International Experiences in the Process of Implementing Smart Cities

Urban security technologies are crucial for the realization of smart city projects, the improvement of public safety, and the advancement of urban planning. In this chapter, we analyse the successful implementation processes of these technologies in the most well-known smart cities, Singapore, Dubai, and Barcelona. We attempt to anticipate the implications for Moroccan cities wishing to introduce these technologies into urban digitization processes.

Singapore is known for its expertise in complex traffic management systems, which rely on extensive networks of surveillance cameras equipped with AI capabilities, continuously and real-time monitoring traffic (Patruni, 2022). These sensors can collect massive data on users committing speed violations, vehicles, densities, and patterns on controlled roads, thereby enabling the optimization of time and efficiency in urban planning (Morisson, 2021). The city of Singapore has invested unprecedented skills to successfully achieve this level of infrastructure digitization and make these technological devices smart for services and urban planning (Liu and Ting, 2021).

In Spain, the transformation of European societies and massive urbanization pose several problems for decision-makers who can leverage technological potentials to overcome their management and planning challenges. The local authorities of Madrid and Barcelona, with more than 33% of the Spanish population expected to reside in these cities by 2035, are facing unforeseen scenarios and multiple challenges, leading to various problems. To address these issues, Spanish policymakers, particularly those from the local government of Barcelona, have adopted an ambitious project for the digitization of the city and its main areas and services (Gil-Alonso et al. 2021).

The Spanish city of Barcelona is one of the earliest smart cities to have implemented smart street lighting, a system of sensors to regulate lighting based on movement in the street area. The devices allowed for autonomous lighting adjustments without the need for on-site teams. They used sophisticated motion detectors and light sensors for this purpose, allowing streetlights to dim when there is no one around and to illuminate in response to the approach of pedestrians or vehicles. This reduced consumption by nearly 30% and improved public safety in urban areas during the night (Capgemini Research Institute 2020).

For the implementation of this project in Barcelona, experts confirmed that it is the result of a long collaboration between several actors and stakeholders. Urban planners, technology providers, and local communities of the city contributed to the implementation of this complex project. The lighting project in Barcelona uses special algorithms to analyze data collected by sensors, allowing central systems to easily adapt while adjusting to environmental curves (Dubbeldeman et al. 2015). This initiative has helped reduce crime rates in poorly lit areas and improve the perception and sense of security among residents (Ϝеrrеr 2017). However, the lighting technology and the way it adjusts the light based on people’s actions and movements in the space also raise ethical concerns.

The use of urban security technologies in smart cities has been a subject of debate, with Morocco and other countries considering the potential risks and challenges associated with their implementation.

In Morocco, cities like Rabat and Marrakech aim to improve public safety while reducing energy costs by adopting facial recognition technology. However, it is crucial that these cities take into account the potential abuses of these technologies, particularly those for detecting movements and activities, and involve citizens in the implementation and development process of these projects. Dubai, a young country, is committed to becoming an innovative nation in various fields, including climate change, governmental innovation, and regulatory innovation. To achieve these ambitions, Dubai has focused on smart governance, transportation management, and optimizing energy consumption by handling individual movements through facial recognition. Supported by Blockchain technologies and IoT devices, the city’s efforts aim to improve the quality of life, attract investments, strengthen the business environment, and position the city as an advanced futuristic hub in technological innovations and public urban security projects based on the adoption of digital devices (The Guardian 2019).

Dubai is one of the few international cities to have adopted facial recognition as a key element of its urban security strategy. To enhance public safety in the city through the use of urban security devices, Dubai’s decision-makers have implemented this technology in important and vital areas with a dense and mobile population (Telecom Review Asia 2024). These systems use advanced algorithms to recognize and match faces captured by surveillance cameras with databases containing information about individuals, directly consulting online security services. This facilitates the rapid identification of potential threats and accelerates emergency operations (Al Zaabi and Zamri 2022).

However, the implementation of this technology raises important ethical and security questions, similar to those of its counterparts, in relation to concerns about privacy and security. Critics argue that these processes can lead to potential misuse of these technologies to infringe on citizens’ privacy and the sense of irresponsibility that may result from the ease and accessibility of collecting individual data (Wang et al. 2024). To avoid these implications, the authorities in Dubai are trying to minimize the risks associated with the appropriate implementation of urban security technologies by applying strict data protection measures and establishing regulations governing the responsible and trustworthy use of data collected by facial recognition technologies.

In Morocco, facial recognition technologies can offer unprecedented potential to improve public safety as well as the speed and efficiency of certain services. However, they can also be dangerous and lead to social unrest and public insecurity by violating privacy, pushing people to rebel against and reject these technologies, being incompatible with legal and moral principles, and breaking people’s trust. This can lead citizens and other important stakeholders to feel excluded and see their opinions and viewpoints ignored when these technologies are used in cities.

Additional case studies and implications for Morocco include Tunisia, where the capital Tunis is exploring the possibilities of integrating mobile applications with urban security systems, and Amman, the capital of Jordan, which has implemented integrated traffic management solutions to monitor roads and streets (Jordan Times 2024). Moroccan cities could benefit from similar urban challenges to mitigate the impacts of the country’s massive privatization. However, several other challenges seem to be present in the efforts of these cities and the integration of security technologies in this process.

A Comparative Presentation Between the National Experience and International Experiences

Morocco has focused on digitizing its infrastructure, economy, and governance systems to maximize the benefits of technology. However, challenges such as overpopulation, pollution, high crime rates, and energy, social, and digital bills have delayed these ambitions. Morocco has undertaken a specific project to digitize Moroccan cities, which serves as an alternative for local and national decision-makers to counter the impacts of contemporary challenges (Zaanoun 2023).

Urban security technologies offer an opportunity to address certain challenges and serve as a foundation for addressing future questions and problems. Similar initiatives in Singapore, Barcelona, and Dubai have helped local authorities overcome several urban management and administration problems and challenges (Burns et al. 2013). These experiences can be compared to Morocco’s initiative for Moroccan cities and how they can benefit from shared lessons, innovations, and contextual adaptations.

Singapore has succeeded in addressing challenges such as overpopulation, urban density, and crime through its Smart Nation initiative. This initiative succeeded thanks to Singapore’s limited space, funding, technical expertise, and the trust of international partners in the country’s authorities. Barcelona has adopted a similar process but with some specificities, focusing on the digitization of urban tasks and adopting technologies aimed at energy optimization and the continuity of public services under the best conditions for citizens.

Dubai’s dream of becoming an innovative city in tourism and foreign investments has been realized through the digitization of various urban tasks and activities, including facial recognition and the analysis of individual traffic data in densely populated areas. The local management of cities and Emirates in the United Arab Emirates and the presence of immense foreign funding and expertise have facilitated the implementation of a digital local planning system, prioritizing the consolidation of investments and overall security rather than focusing on the specifics of the citizens (Al-Dabbagh 2022).

Morocco’s innovative governance initiative aims to address the problems faced by other countries and cities through the adoption of IoT devices (El Allaki et al. 2023). However, the lack of necessary funds to transform this local project into a national project promotes territorial vision and decentralization, negatively impacting the quality of life of citizens and disadvantaging the harmonious living environment.

The cities studied have adopted technologies that make them more resilient to the problems they have previously endured. For example, Singapore has adopted big data analysis through AI to avoid unpredictable scenarios of overpopulation and population density, while Barcelona and Dubai have adopted technologies for energy efficiency driven by IoT and traffic control through facial recognition using blockchains and AI.

The Moroccan model, in partnership with international companies in smart cities, has selected Casablanca and its projects Casablanca Smart and Casablanca City and Zenata Eco City, followed by Rabat and Tangier (Rharbi and İnceoğlu 2022). The establishment of smart infrastructures supporting urban life in these cities presents a territorial challenge in Morocco, as the generalization of this project across the entire national territory, particularly in less urbanized areas, is likely to remain a complex challenge to address in the coming years (Directorate of Territorial Planning 2014).

The difficulties associated with the construction and sharing of this infrastructure at the national level lie in the territorial disparities between the regions of Morocco and the socio-economic context within the same cities of a Moroccan region. Morocco does not have large budgets to follow these examples in detail, but the advantages of these examples in terms of openness, inclusivity, and open source should be closely monitored to develop the Moroccan model based on the principles of accessibility, openness, and citizenship (Ibourk and Raoui 2021).

Sustainability is a common goal in digitalization strategies around the world, with experiences like those of Singapore and Barcelona aligning with global recommendations for carbon reduction and ensuring the sustainability of urban spaces. Dubai’s initiative aligns with international efforts to optimize energy resources and smart management in the energy sector (Viloso, Fonseca and Ramos 2024).

Morocco’s initiative, despite its needs, also constitutes an important piece in the overall strategy for the sustainability of human spaces and urban areas. The initiatives in renewable energy and Morocco’s projects to optimize its energy resources, such as the Noor Ouarzazate station, promote sustainability.

Recommendations for Better Implementation of Smart City Technologies

The national cybersecurity strategy of Morocco is a step forward to improve and strengthen the digital environment in Morocco. However, it lacks specific provisions for the development of smart city projects. To address this, Morocco should develop a robust national urban security strategy that takes into account regional plans for urban cities. This strategy should prioritize the integration of technological devices that improve citizens’ lives and facilitate access to urban services, such as surveillance cameras, biometric facial recognition systems, and AI in the analysis and processing of big data.

The city of Barcelona has demonstrated the effectiveness of facial recognition technologies in managing the flow of travelers and individuals in public transport areas, quickly and efficiently addressing undesirable activities. The city of Belo Horizonte has adopted a low-cost infrastructure system that adapts to human activities in the area surrounding streetlights, reducing emergency response times and improving public safety by addressing the needs of residents in dark areas.

Morocco can also consider adopting and implementing urban security technologies, community guidelines, and integrating public consultations into the smart city urbanization processes. These processes would help establish trust between the components of society, whether they are authorities or citizens, and encourage local authorities to respect the concerns and priorities of local populations.

Diversifying collaboration and research partnerships for the development of smart cities is crucial for the future of Morocco’s cyber strategy. Partnerships between the public and private sectors are recommended when these hybrid agreements are essential to address the challenges and threats of modern cities. Collaborations with technology companies, researchers, and municipal government organizations have proven effective in implementing efficient monitoring systems and public information technologies.

Moroccan authorities can leverage collaboration and cooperation experiences to achieve their goals of developing plans and strategies aimed at transforming Moroccan cities more effectively and efficiently. The establishment of partnerships with research institutions can stimulate innovation in urban security technologies and improve the effectiveness of plans and strategies for transforming Moroccan cities.

In conclusion, Morocco’s national cybersecurity strategy should focus on developing a robust national urban security strategy based on technological integration, emphasizing the integration of surveillance cameras, biometric facial recognition systems, and AI in the analysis and processing of big data.

Morocco takes the digital divide seriously in its national cybersecurity strategy, deploying enormous capacities to reduce this obstacle. The gap between infrastructure development and the sophistication of new urban security technologies can impose disruptions in the integration process. Therefore, ensuring the level of infrastructure is essential before launching plans and strategies for smart urbanization, particularly for the introduction of security technologies.

The Moroccan Code 212 Center, a new ministerial initiative, is a significant step in the training of national skills and experts in cybersecurity, programming, and IoT. This initiative should be extended to universities, vocational training centers, and secondary education institutions in order to multiply its benefits and positive impacts in the field of education and digital training for experts and specialists. Mobile educational training units can be deployed in all regions of the affected cities to inform citizens about the changes that will impact their activities after the implementation of urban security technologies. Public institutions and facilities equipped with Internet access and other resources can help raise awareness among citizens and serve as training and information dissemination centers.

Involving citizens in the management and planning affairs of smart cities is crucial. This process offers great potential to community authorities to undertake joint initiatives and involve citizens in local development and planning policies. The involvement of citizens shapes the development of smart security applications in a social manner, respecting the concerns of the entire community and improving citizens’ access to public services. In the local application of these ideas, Moroccan cities have aimed to develop citizens’ access to local affairs, particularly the work related to the issues under discussion. Digital platforms for consultations and public inquiry requests are essential for developing urban security initiatives.

To understand the long-term implications of urban security technology in the broad Moroccan context of socio-economic and ethical implications, Morocco should develop a broader approach that takes into account social requirements, particularly social inequalities, development in targeted areas, and the integration of the targeted community. Policies for integrating public security technologies into digitization processes and the development of smart cities must prioritize social equity, citizen integration, the sustainability of smart city initiatives, and several other contextual issues to avoid inequalities in access to enhanced security services and minimize the environmental impact of urban security technologies.

Morocco should draw inspiration from international practices and take into account foreign experiences in this field. The development of public-private partnerships is also essential to promote the participation of citizens and other interested stakeholders. This broad integration policy will minimize the digital divide both technically and socially, thus enabling Morocco to develop a solid urban security framework that combines the effectiveness of public safety with urban development.

Conclusion

The integration of urban security technologies, such as IoT sensors, AI-assisted camera surveillance, and biometric identification systems, can enhance public safety, optimize governance, and promote sustainable urban development. However, these technologies often show an ignorance or deliberate rejection of social, economic, environmental, and other factors that can affect our lives when applied in urban spaces. A well-defined national strategy, including ethics, law, freedoms, collaboration, and cooperation, is essential to find long-term solutions.

Moroccan cities should take into account the experiences of international smart cities like Singapore and Barcelona, which have succeeded in overcoming urban challenges through urban technologies. These cities use specific communication processes to strengthen citizens’ trust in the methods of using and protecting their data and personal information. This approach involves engaging citizens and local communities in the deployment of these technologies, ensuring that continuous improvements meet the needs and expectations of the citizens.

To facilitate the implementation of urban security technologies, Morocco should consider forming a national smart cities committee or an interministerial or intercommunal council dedicated to addressing issues related to Moroccan smart cities. This initiative can ensure the effective implementation of digitization processes, facilitate coordination between community authorities at the national level, and align the concerned cities with the common objectives of a national smart city strategy.

This platform will serve as a national platform for sharing responses and information, facilitating the integration of the public and private sectors, and encouraging partnerships between national companies in this field and international companies as well as research institutes managing such projects on a global scale.

Morocco must base its strategy for deploying urban security technologies on the priorities of its citizens, with an emphasis on digital literacy and ensuring equal access to technologies, particularly in rural areas. This can be achieved by mobilizing the necessary skills and leveraging centers and institutions such as the Morocco Code 212 initiative, which will provide training and education to involve young people and citizens in the integration of urban security technologies and their digital and social inclusion.

Urban security technologies can pose environmental challenges, so Morocco should introduce measures to minimize the impacts of energy consumption by prioritizing smart lighting solutions and adopting policies and plans to recycle and reuse damaged equipment. Long-term and strategic planning to anticipate the impacts of urban security technologies will also reduce social disparities and strengthen equity among social categories, thereby reducing inequalities between targeted areas within cities despite economic, cultural, and social variations.

In conclusion, Morocco will succeed in its projects if it understands that only the adoption of a comprehensive, open, and inclusive urban security strategy is the envisaged solution to build smart cities in parallel with the country’s ambitions in all fields.

References
Al-Dabbagh, Riadh. 2022. “Dubai, the Sustainable, Smart City.” Renewable Energy and Environmental Sustainability. 7(3). 1-12 http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/rees/2021049.
Belguidoum, Saïd, Raffaele Cattedra, and Aziz Iraki. 2015. “Cities and Urbanity in the Maghreb.” L’Année Du Maghreb 12(12): 11–32. http://dx.doi.org/10.4000/anneemaghreb.2510.
BrittJones. 2024. “Balancing Security and Privacy: Ethical Considerations in Video Surveillance Systems – Security Middle East Magazine.” Security Middle East Magazine. https://www.securitymiddleeastmag.com/security-privacy-video-surveillance/ (Accessed August 11, 2024).
Burns, Malcolm C., Carlos Marmolejo, Josep Roca, Eduardo Chica and Jordi Freixas. 2013. “The Case for Agglomeration Economies in Europe”. Department of Political Science, Universitat de Barcelona. https://archive.espon.eu/sites /default/files/attachments/ CAEE_Barcelona_Case_Study_Appendix_C4_FINAL.pdf (Accessed October 1, 2024).
Costa, Daniel G., João Carlos N. Bittencourt, Franklin Oliveira, João Paulo Just Peixoto, and Thiago C. Jesus. 2024b. “Achieving Sustainable Smart Cities through Geospatial Data-Driven Approaches.” Journal of Sustainability 16(2): 640. doi:10.3390/su16020640.
Elmaghraby, Adel S., and Michael M. Losavio. 2014. “Cyber Security Challenges in Smart Cities: Safety, Security and Privacy.” Journal of Advanced Research 5(4): 491–97. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jare.2014.02.006.
Ferrer. J., Ramon. 2017. “Barcelona’s Smart City vision: an opportunity for transformation”. Journal of Fiels Actions 16 (Sup1). 70-77. https://journals.openedition.org/factsreports/4367.
Fontes, Catarina, Ellen Hohma, Caitlin C. Corrigan, and Christoph Lütge. 2022. “AI-powered public surveillance systems: why we (might) need them and how we want them”. Technology in Society 71 . 102-137. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techsoc.2022.102137.
Ibourk, Aomar, and Soukaina Raoui. 2021. “Scale Effect on Territorial Disparities of Sustainable Human Development in Morocco: A Spatial Analysis.” Discover Sustainability 2(57).1-20. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43621-021-00068-1.
Khalifi, H., Riahi, S., and Cherif, W. 2024. “Smart Cities and Sustainable Urban Development in Morocco”. Ingénierie Des Systèmes D’Information 29(2). https://doi.org/10.18280/isi.290236.
Khan, Nimra., and Efthymiou Marina. 2021. “The use of biometric technology at airports: The case of customs and border protection (CBP)”. International Journal of Information Management Data Insights 1(2), 100-049. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jjimei.2021.100049.
Kolotouchkina, olga, Ripoll Laura., and Belabas Warda. 2024. “Smart Cities, Digital Inequalities, and the Challenge of Inclusion”. Journal of Smart Cities 7(6). 2256-2270. http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/smartcities7060130.
Liu, H., and Wang, T.-Yang. 2021. “The institutionalization and effectiveness of transnational policy transfer: The China–Singapore Suzhou Industrial Park as a case study”. Public Administration and Development 41(3), 103-114. https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.1956.
Nakar, Sharon, Dov Greenbaum, Zvi Meitar Family, Liana G., and Inbar Carmel. 2017. “Now You See Me. now you still do: facial recognition technology and the growing lack of privacy”. Journal of Science & Technology Law 23(7). 88-123. https://www.bu.edu/jostl/files/2017/04/Greenbaum-Online.pdf.
Patruni, M., and Deebak, B. D. 2022. “Security and privacy issues in smart cities/industries: technologies, applications, and challenges”. Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing 14(8), 1-37. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12652-022-03707-1.
Rharbi, Noussaiba, and Mehmet İnceoğlu. 2022. “Moroccan New Green Cities, towards a Green Urban Transition.” Journal of Islamic Architecture 7(2): 296–305. http://dx.doi.org/10.18860/jia.v7i2.17222.
Thakuriah, Tilahun, and Moira L. 2015. “Big Data and Urban Informatics: Innovations and Challenges to Urban Planning and Knowledge Discovery.” In Seeing Cities through Big Data: Research, Methods and Applications in Urban Informatics. Springer NY. 4–33. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-40902-3.
Townsend, M. Anthony. 2013. Smart Cities: Big Data, Civic Hackers, and the Quest for a New Utopia. 1st ed. Norton & Company.
Wang, X., Wu, Y. C., Zhou, M., and Fu, H. 2024. “Beyond surveillance: privacy, ethics, and regulations in face recognition technology”. Frontiers in Big Data 7. https://doi.org/10.3389/fdata.2024.1337465.
Woetzel, L., Remes, J., Boland, B., Lv, K., Sinha, S., Strube, G., Means, J., Law, J., Cadena, A., and Von Der Tann, V. 2018. “Smart cities: Digital solutions for a more livable future”. McKinsey & Company. https://www.mckinsey .com/capabilities/operations/our-insights/smart-cities-digital-solutions-for-a-more-livable-future (Accessed July 22, 2024).
Zaabi, S. H. A., & Zamri, R. 2022. “Managing Security Threats through Touchless Security Technologies: An Overview of the Integration of Facial Recognition Technology in the UAE Oil and Gas Industry”. Journal of Sustainability 14(22), 1-32. https://doi.org/10.3390/su142214915.
Zaanoun, Abderrafie. 2023. “Morocco : The Impact of the Digitization of Public Services.” Arab Reform Initiative. https://www.arab-reform.net/publication /morocco-the-impact-of-the-digitization-of-public-services/ (Accessed October 22, 2024).